In this 2 part episode, the Cold Justice Team investigates two different murder cases at the same time. A 1992 sexual assault and stabbing death of Laura Walsh in her home, and, months later, a double homicide of two young men, Gene Giddens and Jonathan "Keith" Durington, whose throats were slashed. Both crimes happened in the same neighborhood and all 3 victims were set on fire after their deaths leaving local law enforcement with three unsolved murders. The team will have to determine if these two cases are potentially connected, and help bring whomever is responsible to justice.