Jude finds out that he has a lucky zit, while Wyatt becomes depressed because he can't manage to get a girlfriend after his last date disaster. Jonesy gives him "The List," which is a list of girls he had previously dated and short details about them, which leads to Nikki and him having a fight about how long have they dated and Nikki declaring that they are going to have a break from each other until Jonesy can figure out why and how he's dating her. Near the end, Jonesy finally declares Nikki as "The One," mostly what Caitlin calls every boy that she dates. Meanwhile at Albatross & Finch, Caitlin notices she had lost her credit card and she sets out to find it, with help from Jen, by tracing purchases made on the card after its disappearance.