This week, we narrowed the field of Nashville Star contestants from five to four, and our four remaining contestants each performed a #1 song (post-1999), as well as an original song they HOPED would be #1 someday. Remaining finalists/Phil Vassar: "Just Another Day in Paradise" - Phil Vassar John Arthur Martinez: "But for the Grace of God" - Keith Urban "Home Made of Stone" - original Brandi Gibson: "How Do You Like Me Now" - Toby Keith "Take Her Picture" - original Buddy Jewell: "It Must Be Love" - Don Williams/Alan Jackson "Abeline" - original Miranda Lambert: "Somebody Like You" - Keith Urban "Oh, California" - original