Lucy mistakenly hires a male stripper for Ian on Valentine's Day. Later, their romantic dinner is ruined by Kevin. After biting Elizabeth, Joshua suggests they feed off each other but Elizabeth runs to Ian's only to discover he & Lucy are sleeping together. Alison voices her displeasure with Rafe & Jack's plan of using Tess to get Caleb. Rafe gets Ali to forget their argument for the night. Tess hears Caleb's music and follows it to Caleb, who plays his new song for her, then gives her a music box. Later, Tess prepares to spend Valentine's with Jack, but plays the music box. When Jack comes home, he's met by Livvie!