As Ricky tries to resign himself to the fact that he will never see Casey again, Karen and Frank happen by and are amazed to see that the young man's scar has completely vanished. Rattled to discover the word ""Trouble"" printed on the bottom of one of Rebecca's candles, Livvie decides to enlist some help from Jamal. Meanwhile, Alison and Jack find Rebecca's belongings stacked in the barn. After Jack recognizes the portrait as a likeness of Paige, Alison realizes that the woman who saved her life was not Rebecca after all. Livvie explains to Jamal how obsessed Alison has become with her creepy ancestor. Later, while researching the history of the Barrington clan, Livvie notes Paige's startling resemblance to Rebecca and wonders if her father's old flame is also a witch. As he sifts through Rebecca's things, Jack unearths an antique camera and playfully snaps Alison's picture. Ricky is perplexed by another sighting of Casey outside the Recovery Room. Jamal and Livvie learn that Rebecca wa